Insufficient protection and too slow: why European Union regulations are "not well suited" to the EFAS problem

Share:

European regulations are not suitable for responding to EFAS, according to a report by the European Court of Auditors (ECA) published on Wednesday November 18. The Commission must move plus quickly, by promoting cross-section restrictions on substance-by-substance examination which has hitherto taken precedence, press the body.

The European Court of Auditors (ECA) has looked into the effectiveness of the measures taken by the European Union to protect the health of its inhabitants of the PSAS. Verdict: its legal frame “is not well suited” to the issue posed by these “forever chemicals.” "The sector is making very rapid progress and the political world must catch up," said Joëlle Elvinger, ECA member in charge of the report, published this Wednesday, November 18.

These per-and polyfluoroalkylated compounds are distinguished by their great persistence in bodies and the ecological stability. This substantial family, broadly applied in sector and consumer items to its non-stick, waterproof or anti-fire characteristics, includes thousands of different molecules. Some of them have various proven toxic impacts on humans (carcinogenic, reproductive toxicant, etc.).

At European level, the PSAS are mainly regulated by the REACH regulation, which regulates chemical substances. Their prohibition or restriction of consumption is made molecule by molecule. A risk assessment lasts an average of Six years, then, if a restriction procedure is initiated, it takes an average of five greater years before it comes into force, the rapporteurs have calculated. That is 11 years overall.

“When a restriction is put in place, or even beforehand, sector typically finds substitutes that lead to the substitution of the targeted PFAS, which might pose similar risks.” “These processes therefore take too much time and do not result in efficiently protection,” explains José Parente, the auditor who is also working on the report. "However, we have found that there are substitutes even within the legislation, such as cross-section restrictions," he continued, such as the one in 2020 aimed at the removal of fire foals containing EFAS, all molecules combined.

In 2021, several countries tabled a proposal to restrict the entire family of EFAS, in tous their uses. Its examination phase is still underway and should lead to a decision-making phase of the European Commission, estimated on average at 26 months. Too long, the rapporteurs still judge. The ECA therefore recommends that Brussels "speed up the procedure leading to a decision on the current proposal to a universal restriction of the EFAS" by the end of 2027, and "rationalize the procedures related to the legislation on chemicals" to regulate plus rapidly the FFPs.

Another blind spot by the report, the PSAS are still very little monitored. The principle of "no data, no market" is applied very little to this family. Manufacturers and importers of chemicals in the EU are required to provide technical and security information to the competent agency, ECHA, without which the substances cannot be marketed in the EU. however, only substances produced or imported plus 1,000 tonnes per year must provide complete toxicological and ecotoxicological test data. In addition, the registration procedure does not apply to polymers. The majority of the EFAS fall into at least one of the two categories, thus escaping these obligations.

As to environmental surveillance, it is also considered to be poor. The data requested by the EU is provided very unevenly depending on the member states: five never provided between 2020 and 2024, Greece provided five results, and Germany plus 90,000. The cost of testing has notably been pointed out as an obstacle. France is nevertheless one of the good students according to the ECA, alongside the Netherlands or Denmark.

Some molecules also escape the radar. In particular, the report drew attention to trifluoroacetic acid (TFA), on which the European Food security Authority (EFSA) has "no monitoring data." Often resulting from the degradation of other PFAS, it has have become the plus widespread in the ecological stability.

Quick inquiry

Create

Inquiry Sent

We will contact you soon